Voting without debate is not democratic

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 06/26/16.

After my last article on Brexit, some readers have asked me to further develop my proposal for deliberative democracy. It is one of the tools analyzed within decision theory, an interdisciplinary area related to economics, psychology, mathematics and sociology, which analyzes how social agents make their decisions. 

We have, not a dilemma, but a “trilemma”, when choosing between elective, direct or deliberative democracy. No system meets the three conditions required for a perfect democracy: political equality, mass participation, and informed and reasoned deliberation. The first two are fulfilled with direct or plebiscitary democracy. The last two with elective democracy, and deliberative democracy would comply with equality and deliberation, but not with mass participation. 

The defects of elective democracy are clear and are summarized in a disconnection between voters and those elected, who, when drafting laws, allow themselves to be influenced by pressure groups to the detriment of the interest of citizens, who are less informed and involved in day-to-day legislative work. The advantage of elective democracy is that, it is assumed, those elected have the time and resources necessary to make an informed decision on sometimes very complex issues, which would not be possible in a direct democracy.

Ideally, millions of citizens would deliberate and make decisions directly, but most are not really interested in dedicating their free time and efforts to these issues, nor do they think that their opinion is really relevant, since it is one among several millions. The cost of informing millions of people would be enormous, and, furthermore, they are vulnerable to manipulation, since they receive incomplete, falsified and scarce information, based on repeated and easy-to-remember catchphrases, given the little attention they pay to the matter. The examples of the referendums on Scottish independence or Brexit are good examples of momentous decisions where the information received by citizens is incomplete and self-serving, and where emotional arguments frequently outweigh rational ones. And yet, those poorly informed citizens who have dedicated little time and effort to making a reasoned decision will later have to assume the consequences of their collective decision. Through deliberation, we would try to get the majority of people to agree with the solution that is going to be taken or the path that they are going to follow. For this, a representative microcosm of the population that deliberates could be a second best, it is not the ideal but the one that comes closest, since it would offer an image of what the people would think if they dedicated the time and effort necessary to inform themselves, if the information was complete and unbiased, and if they thought that their decision was relevant both for its weight and for its consequences.

We have a successful mixed example of deliberative and direct democracy in one of the American states most inclined to consult almost anything with citizens: Oregon, where in 1904 the first popular consultation in the United States was held. In recent years, these initiatives were receiving increasingly furious criticism because, in many cases, behind the Popular Legislative Initiatives (ILP) were hidden very particular interest groups (lobbies) and well organized, which were in charge of collecting the necessary signatures and spending large sums of money on advertising campaigns where they distorted or hid relevant information from the public, without another group with a similar interest confronting and contradicting them. The tactic of these interest groups was to obtain votes, not to inform, so the data they offered was distorted. Likewise, the multiplication of popular initiatives of all kinds led to increasingly lower participation in organized consultations, where barely between 10% and 30% of registered voters voted, reducing their democratic legitimacy.

For all these reasons, since 2011 in Oregon it has been legislated that a panel of citizens review, debate and approve conclusions about the ILPs that are presented to be submitted to a referendum. For each of them, a group of 24 citizens is selected randomly and proportionally to the population to review each initiative. Selected citizens meet for three to five days and are compensated with attendance and travel allowances. During those days they meet with independent experts, as well as with groups that support or reject the proposal that is going to be submitted to the referendum. Finally, they deliberate on what they have heard and prepare a “Citizen Declaration” in which they highlight the most relevant conclusions reached after the debate, as well as the most important arguments for and against. This declaration is delivered to each home before the referendum, in order to provide citizens with the most impartial non-partisan information possible on the issue to be voted on. Independent research carried out in 2012 demonstrated that citizen statements were impartial, widely used by citizens and that the majority of citizens considered them the most useful tool in deciding their vote.

This initiative was awarded in 2013 with the awards for the best national and international project by the International Association for Public Participation. I consider that it is a well-directed initiative that should be taken into account to combine the best of direct and deliberative democracy. It is not a decision procedure necessarily based on consensus, but it is a prerequisite for majority voting, under the premise that voting without discussion is not democratic.

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.