Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 10/25/15.
The PSOE has proposed in its draft electoral program to raise the minimum interprofessional salary (SMI) to around 1,000 euros in two terms. This would mean going from 648 euros in 14 payments today to 1,000 euros per month, an increase of 54% in eight years. From time to time, the minimum wage returns to the center of the debate. The economy does not have one labor market, but many, depending on the type of workers. The effect of the minimum wage depends on the qualification and experience of the worker, since it does not affect those who have high qualifications and experience, since their salary is higher than the minimum, but it does affect unskilled workers and young people without experience. The effect of the minimum wage on employment is well studied in economic theory. If the minimum wage is higher than that received by unskilled workers, its effect will be to raise the income of workers who maintain their jobs and displace those who do not maintain their employment into unemployment or the underground economy. And some activities with little added value and intensive use of labor cannot survive with higher salaries. Its increase has another side effect, such as that some people (especially young people) who were studying abandon their studies to work at the new and higher salaries. These young people displace unskilled adult workers, who are now left unemployed. Therefore, if an attempt is made to improve income redistribution, the SMI is not a good instrument.
Do all countries establish a minimum wage? No, but most of them do. In the European Union, 21 of the 28 countries have it, although its amount varies. Spain is the eighth country in the EU with the highest minimum wage. However, in Europe, countries as little suspected of extreme liberalism as Denmark, Sweden, Iceland, Finland, Austria or Switzerland, have not established any. The current level of the SMI in Spain (35% of the average salary) affects less than 2% of the total employment contracts of adults, which explains why moderate increases in it do not usually have a significant negative effect on adult employment. But an increase in the proposed amount (54%) would affect 33% of workers and would place us among the countries with a higher relative minimum wage (compared to the average wage). It seems that they have gotten out of hand. Furthermore, there is evidence that increases in the SMI have had a negative impact on youth employment even before the crisis, given that the productivity of a young person without qualifications or experience is not enough for companies to hire them for this salary. In many countries they differentiate the minimum wage by age groups. In Spain it was eliminated in 1998, but countries such as Belgium, France, Australia or the US have different minimum wages depending on the age of the worker. A lower, and not higher, minimum wage for young people would reduce the unemployment rate of unskilled young people (close to 70%), as well as the school dropout rate (25%).
There are also many unskilled people among adults, but for them it does not seem that the appropriate solution involves changes in the level of the SMI. There are better ways to fight the growing phenomenon of the working poor. Thus, it is more reasonable to look for formulas to reduce labor costs through reductions in social contributions for low-skilled workers or with salary supplements. Regarding the latter, in the United States there is a successful model to combat poverty for low-income workers called Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC), which works very well. There, a household without children with an annual income of $9,000 receives a supplement of $496/year (a 5.5% increase in income); with one child, $3,069/year (a 34.1% increase); with two, $3,610 (+40.1%); and with three, $4,061/year (+45.1%). The EITC even has proven long-term positive effects on the well-being of the children of families who receive it. In 2013, thanks to this program, 6.2 million people left poverty and the number of poor children was reduced by 25%. Likewise, the program reduced the severity of poverty for 21.6 million people, including 7.8 million children. There it is also considered the most successful measure to return new mothers to employment.
Ciudadanos proposes something similar with its Guaranteed Annual Salary Supplement (CSAG). The idea consists, on the one hand, of helping low-income workers with additional income through personal income tax refunds and, on the other, creating an incentive to incorporate more workers into the market and remove some from the underground economy. Unlike “basic income”, the CSAG encourages and rewards those who work, since it is received only by those who have worked in the fiscal year, and it does so by ensuring that income grows when more hours are worked or more household members find work. Its promoters assure that it has nothing to do with the minimum wage, "which expels less qualified workers from the market." The CSAG encourages low-skilled workers to work and makes it easier for employment, even if it is part-time, to have a decent remuneration. Since, in addition, a good part of the income from the salary supplement would be allocated to consumption, part of that expense would revert back to society. In fact, in the United States, 75% of spending on the EITC returns to the economy, which which is not bad at all.
And what we really need are more policies with proven success and more serene debate between experts, politicians and social agents about what works and what doesn't, and fewer electoral occurrences, even if they give votes.
U!



