Article by José Alberto León Alonso, published on 12/8/13 in Diario de Avisos.
The Lisbon Strategy indicates that human capital is a productive resource that not only contributes to economic growth, but is also one of the basic pillars to achieve equal opportunities in our society. Hence the importance of a good educational system. The LOGSE pedagogical model is a model that has been rectified in all Western countries where it was implemented less in Spain. For the “Taliban” of postmodern pedagogy, knowledge is unimportant, only \»learning to learn\» matters.
Faced with this opinion, the Government has brought forward a new education law: the LOMCE. The opposition has been the majority, at least because of the number of demonstrations that we have been able to witness in the last year. The curious thing is that, as Professor Martínez Lázaro from the IE Business School says, we have never seen a demonstration of condemnation for the poor results of our students in the PISA tests, nor for having the highest school failure rates in Europe, nor for university education and vocational training that are inadequate for the needs of the labor market.
The analysis of the new law has focused on our recurring demons: the teaching of religion, the primacy or not of public education over private education, and teaching in Spanish in communities with their own language. Sterile and ideological debates without educational relevance. Does anyone think that the educational level will change if religion counts or not for the academic grade? Will school failure be reduced? In my analysis I will not go into any of those topics. I have my opinion, but I also assume that the criteria regarding them could be changed every year without the educational level of our young people improving or worsening one bit. I will focus on what matters: will this law improve the educational quality of our country? Let's go in parts.
The first group of LOMCE measures has to do with early leaving, and its star measure is the anticipation of the choice of itineraries in ESO. It establishes two routes for the 4th year of ESO, one oriented towards Baccalaureate and the other towards vocational training, which gives this course a preparatory character. It is a good idea, but it would have been more logical to start a three-year Baccalaureate instead, as is the case in 90% of Europe. As it has been designed, a student who does not study biology or physics can go to the scientific baccalaureate and those who do not study Latin can go to the humanistic one, which will require repeating at least part of the syllabus in 1st year of Baccalaureate. A waste of time. The logical thing would have been to link the subjects to the chosen baccalaureate modality.
The best achieved chapter of the LOMCE is the second group of measures, which aims to promote employability. In 2nd year of ESO, students who have already repeated twice (with three failed subjects or two, if these are Mathematics and Language) will be able to move on to the new Basic FP (the current PCPI). Basic FP will be a two-year alternative to ESO in which students who are doing worse learn the rudiments of a trade, achieving a professional certificate from the Ministry of Labor. Students who pass these courses will have direct access to the intermediate degree FP and will be able to take the ESO revalidation to obtain the mandatory degree, although it is a possibility that seems illusory. The programs for attention to students with learning problems (the current Curricular Diversification Programs or “Diver”) that are carried out in 3rd and 4th years of ESO are also brought forward to the 2nd year of ESO. By advancing entry into these programs, the risk of some students giving up on the degree, as is happening now, and/or losing a full year trying to pass the 3rd year of ESO, when they do not have the interest or ability to do so, is reduced. A success.
The third group of measures proposes greater emphasis on priority subjects. There is ample evidence that teaching hours are important for performance, but beyond ensuring State control over the content of core subjects, the LOMCE only indicates that at least 50% of teaching hours will be dedicated to these subjects, leaving the specification of the number of teaching hours for each subject to subsequent regulations. With that percentage, if we stay at the minimum we can even reduce teaching hours in some subjects, so in that aspect the LOMCE is far from solving the problem. The future development of the law will determine to what extent some subjects lose and others gain, and whether the excessive number of subjects and teaching hours in “maritime” subjects are reduced in favor of the core subjects, as seems logical.
The fourth group introduces external evaluation to students at the end of each educational stage: primary, ESO and high school. The last two will be revalidated (the student must pass them to continue studying), but the primary one will not be. In this case, the results will serve to guide and the exam will be controlled by the Autonomous Communities, just like another test that centers must take in the 3rd year of primary school, at eight years old. Those who, having passed the 2nd year of high school, do not pass the revalidation, will be able to access higher-level vocational training. External evaluation is another success, since without it it cannot be diagnosed correctly, and there is ample evidence that it is effective in improving the educational level.
The fifth block of measures has to do with the autonomy of the centers. The center's curricular specialization and autonomy are allowed. The specialization of centers is promoted in areas (for example, the route to vocational training or the ESO baccalaureate) or in quality improvement plans (the centers that teach them may have extra funds). The decision-making capacity of parents and teachers to choose between aspiring directors is reduced, putting more weight on the administration, and directors may require profiles for teachers who go to their center for quality projects. In the selection of directors, in addition to undergoing a national competency certification, previous results in other similar positions will be taken into account, and in their re-election the results of the revalidations carried out on students during their mandate will be decisive. I believe that specialization and autonomy can lead us both to a relevant improvement in academic results and to a covert politicization of education, selecting directors based on political clientelism. It remains to be seen if the practice goes one way or the other.
The sixth aspect refers to what is not included in the LOMCE: the selection and promotion of teaching staff. The difficulties in changing the working conditions of teachers are understood, but in education the dominant production factor is teaching work and at the moment efficiency depends on having better teachers, so their selection and motivation are essential. All of this is outside the law.
That is to say, two of the six issues have been well resolved (employability and evaluation), one that remains half done (itineraries), another that will have to be seen how it works in practice (specialization and autonomy of the centers), and two aspects that have not even been addressed (teaching hours and teaching staff). As I said, a half reform.
U!



