Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 04/17/16.
The appearance of the so-called “Panama Papers” is a massive leak of 11.5 million documents that has exposed the relationship of important world figures with the Panamanian law firm Fonseca, the fifth in the country. Spain, moreover, has its own names included in that list: according to El Confidencial and La Sexta, among those millions of documents there are 1,200 companies, 558 shareholders, 166 intermediaries and 89 Spanish beneficiaries.
As always in these cases, the noise that accompanies the news hinders the ability of citizens to separate the wheat from the chaff, the substantial from the accessory. I will try in this article to make an effort in that sense.
To begin with, what is a company for in Panama? At first glance, that country is a place where taxes are very low and seems like a good refuge for those who have been able to accumulate some funds and do not want the insatiable domestic treasury to keep a good part of them. The vast majority of the owners (not the vast majority of the funds) of these companies are people who have obtained their assets from perfectly legal activities: artists, athletes, businessmen, professionals or simply heirs to fortunes, who do not wish to face the strongly progressive income taxes of the countries where they reside. In the past (during the 1980s and 1990s) there were also good operational reasons for a company to maintain offshore accounts if it worked with foreign companies. International transfers were complicated to and from Spain due to delays and obstacles of all kinds, and for this purpose it was more practical to use an account in these countries, where they were more accustomed to this type of transactions. But these operational difficulties have long since disappeared.
Are these companies legal? Of course. But if they are legal, why is this scandal? Until now, journalistic reports have not revealed any crime, not even prosecutorial. After all, any resident in Spain must pay taxes in our country on all their income, whether it was obtained in Spain or abroad, including tax havens. That is, for a resident in Spain (someone who lives in our country for more than half of the year), as long as they comply with their tax obligations and declare the income obtained abroad, there is no tax benefit in the reduced taxation of tax havens. You must pay taxes on all income earned worldwide. But then, if for a resident in Spain who meets his obligations there is no tax benefit in creating a company in those territories, why do they do it?
Some for the security of having their savings distributed in different countries safe from national contingencies (corralitos, embargoes, national bankruptcies, etc.), which is even reasonable depending on where you live. After all, Spain was close to going to hell less than five years ago and many families sought in these refuges a way to save their savings from the eventuality of a blocking of accounts and a forced conversion into a new peseta of little value. Let's not say anything if you live in Argentina and Venezuela, which go bankrupt every twenty years.
Others because they do not declare the income obtained there, and that is illegal and even immoral, especially if in your country of residence you benefit from subsidies that you do not contribute to defraying. Even so, this is not the main fraud problem. The most optimistic estimates of the taxes potentially defrauded by the existence of tax havens barely amount to 1% of the tax revenues of the States, which in Spain would mean just over 4,000 million euros. Taking into account that the 2015 deficit in our country amounted to 55,000 million euros, that figure barely represents 7.2% of the total deficit. It is a peak, but it would not solve any of our tax fraud problems, located in payments made in cash in our own country and not declared.
And finally a few, but they move the majority of the funds, because they use shell companies in order to launder money. And the great popularity of tax havens is due to the secrecy they impose on transactions. A tax haven does not exchange information with the tax authorities of other countries. Nothing is known about the inflows and outflows of money from the accounts of the created company, nor about its participations in other companies, usually other companies located in other tax havens. The usual practice for those who wish to evade controls is to create a shell company in one of these havens and for this company to participate in others, which in turn participate in others that ultimately have the money deposited in another country. All this to hide the name of the true owner of that money.
The most serious thing is that this minority conceals the results of illicit activities and uses these and other companies in order to launder the money from these criminal activities and reintroduce it into the real economy. Thus, arms trafficking, drug trafficking, white slavery, international terrorism and satraps of all stripes use these front companies to hide the results of their illegal activities. Tax havens have become purifiers of black money and refuge for organized criminal groups. And given this fact, countries must act by imposing sanctions not on countries with low taxation, but on those that do not collaborate by providing information. But to be effective it must be a coordinated effort among the majority of developed countries, which has never occurred. Maybe because they are not interested.



