Options for Brexit

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 07/03/16.

The vote in the United Kingdom (UK) in favor of leaving the European Union (Brexit) opens up different possible scenarios to establish a new framework of relations with Europe and the world. What is going to happen now is a complete unknown.

The doubts already begin with the moment at which the United Kingdom will invoke the two-year procedure to leave the EU. In a state of shock, the UK is now a headless chicken. Now that they have decided to leave, the British do not seem to be in much of a hurry to actually do so and are trying to postpone it until the end of 2016, which only increases the discomfort and uncertainty.

But sooner or later, the UK and the EU will negotiate an exit agreement in which basically five possibilities are considered, which, ordered from greater to lesser integration of the UK into the EU, are:

1. The Norwegian model. Norway is not part of the EU, but it is part of the European Economic Area, which includes the single market and the four great freedoms (people, goods, services and capital). It is not part of the euro or the customs union, so it establishes its own tariff rates and agreements with third countries. However, they must implement (without having a say) European legislation on employment, consumer protection, the environment and competition, as well as contribute to the community budget. This model allows free access without customs controls of Norwegian products to the EU, while retaining the sovereignty to negotiate treaties with third countries. 

2. The swiss model. Switzerland and the EU have bilateral a la carte agreements (about 130) which establish the free movement of goods and people between both parties. Switzerland contributes to the community budget and is involved in certain internal market rules, although not all. However, every time European legislation is modified, both parties must renegotiate the agreements one by one, which greatly complicates the political relationship. 

3. The turkish model. There is no free movement of people, services or capital, but there is free movement of goods, since Turkey is within the customs union, although some of its products pay a reduced tariff for entering the EU. Türkiye cannot set its own external tariffs, and must also accept preferential agreements between the EU and third countries, but it does not contribute to the community budget. 

4. The canadian model. Similar to Türkiye, but without entering the customs union. It eliminates customs duties on industrial, agricultural and food products, although it maintains them on the rest, as well as on services. Canada maintains its external customs and does not abide by the EU's preferential agreements with third countries.

5. The WTO model (World Trade Organization). It is the disruptive scenario. There would be no deal and the UK would leave the EU in two years with no option to negotiate any treaty or common policy. In this scenario, the UK could join the WTO, which establishes reduced customs tariffs, rules to resolve conflicts and does not provide for the free movement of people. British products would have to pay the same tariff to export to the EU as the rest of the world.

A “Norwegian-style” agreement would be a “Gatopardian” scenario, in which “everything would change so that nothing would change.” For the British it would mean the salvation of the City. On the contrary, it would have no voice or vote in the European institutions, and would have to abide by the decisions that the EU made, in addition to contributing to the community budget. It would be the model that would least modify the current situation and with the least economic impact, but in the end Brexit supporters would not achieve what motivated them most: immigration control and not contributing to the European budget. Furthermore, the British would have to accept what the Europeans decided on all types of matters, instead of hindering or modifying them as they did until now. 

The Swiss model would be an intermediate integration scenario, an ad hoc solution for Switzerland that could well be applied to the UK. It would reduce the British contribution to the EU budget (Switzerland pays around 60% of that of the UK), but it would not eliminate it. Agreements in manufacturing, research, agriculture or pensions would be relatively easy. But agreements on services and, especially, financial agreements would be much more complicated, and would not be reached until after the effective exit. For the UK it would require the free movement of people and contribute to the community budget, although less than now. For the EU it is difficult to manage, due to the continuous renegotiation it requires. In fact, the EU wants Switzerland to move to the Norwegian model.

The Turkish or Canadian model would be more acceptable to Brexit supporters, as they do not imply free movement of people or contributions to the community budget, but any of them would damage the City, as well as the exchange of services which, remember, today have a greater economic weight than that of goods.

Europeans are divided over what attitude to take. The conciliator would lead us to a model halfway between the Swiss and the Turkish, with specific agreements on less sensitive products and limited movement of people, that is, it would not apply to current residents of both the EU and the UK, and a maximum and reciprocal annual limit or quota would be established. Agreements would also be reached on pensions and health, with their economic compensations. The aggressive one is the “out is out” of the President of the Commission, which would end the UK in the WTO model or, at most, in the Canadian one. It would be a complete mess, both for companies and for people. The worst thing about this is that the promoters of Brexit are divided and do not know what they want now that they have won the referendum. So we are left with a long period of uncertainty. The worst for the economy.

U!

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.