They do not represent us

Article published by José Alberto León in El Día on 02/21/16.

In economics, social choice theory deals with making collective decisions based on the preferences of the individuals that make up a society. One of the aspects it analyzes is socially optimal voting methods. And the Canarian electoral system is the most disproportionate in the world, the worst. In the past elections, the paradoxes have been very provocative. The most striking is that one party (ASG) won three seats with just 0.6% of the total votes, while another (Ciudadanos) did not obtain any seats with ten times as many votes (5.93%). Likewise, the three parties with the most votes obtained disparate seats with very similar percentages of votes. And finally, no less than 173,000 votes (almost 20% of the total) went directly to the “trash” as they did not obtain parliamentary representation.

Such paradoxes are produced by two facts. The first is an initial allocation of seats to the island constituencies that is independent of the population. The smaller islands are overrepresented, which makes the vote of one person from El Hierro “worth” as much as that of almost seventeen Tenerife residents. But there are also paradoxes in the representation of the different smaller islands, such that La Palma, with 82,000 inhabitants, elects one more representative than Fuerteventura, with 107,000 inhabitants. For all these reasons, in the Canary Islands no less than 33% of the seats are assigned to electoral constituencies that would not receive them if there were not an inadequate disproportion, and our electoral system turns out to be the most disproportionate in the world, when the world average of disproportion is barely 7% (in Spain 9.6%). The second fact is the high minimums (30% of the votes of an island or 6% of the region) that are required to access Parliament. The reduction of the regional minimum of 6% would have allowed the entry of Citizens into Parliament, but it would not avoid the other paradoxes of the system. 

For these reasons it is not surprising that a Commission is going to be created to analyze the reform of the Canarian electoral system. There are several proposals on the table, but in these lines I will allow myself to outline another for debate that not only solves the problems raised above, but also another, widespread in the different Spanish electoral systems, such as the poor connection and accountability between representatives and represented.

It would be about electing our representatives at two levels. In the first, the island constituencies would be ignored and they would be reduced and brought much closer to the voters, dividing the archipelago into 40 single-person districts with an average of 52,000 inhabitants. In each of them, citizens would have a single ballot on which they would mark the name of their favorite candidate from among the eight or ten possible candidates to choose from, with one and only one being elected, the one with the most votes. Candidates should address a small group of voters, usually grouped by region, with very specific local concerns that they should try to satisfy, since their personal choice would depend on it. The maximum size of the district would be the island, such that El Hierro and La Gomera would elect at least one representative each, but the rest of the islands would be divided into smaller districts. With this, given the low importance of the votes of some regions in the larger islands with respect to the island total and the few deputies elected in these, areas whose interests are now almost absent from Parliament, such as Isla Baja, Valle de Güimar, Abona or Acentejo in Tenerife, they would have their own representative who would ensure that their voice was heard. Of course, with a weight proportional to its population (around 50,000 inhabitants each). Large cities, on the other hand, would elect several deputies, but always with one representative for every 50,000 inhabitants. Thus, Santa Cruz de Tenerife would elect a representative for the central area, another for Ofra-Costa Sur, another in Salud-La Salle and another in the Southwest. Taking into account that the most relevant regional powers (health, education, social services and infrastructure) have an eminently territorial nature, local interests would thus be better represented. Citizens could go to “their” deputy to convey their concerns and the deputies would dedicate a good part of their time to being in contact with their voters, because of the impact it has on them if they wish to be re-elected, which would no longer depend on the position on the list in which they placed them, but on their popularity in their district.

The second level would be regional and would elect twenty deputies. At this level, the number of deputies that would correspond to each party would first be calculated in direct proportion to the percentage of votes obtained throughout the Canary Islands. The parties that had obtained fewer deputies in the district election than those resulting from this calculation in a single constituency, would receive a number of deputies equal to the difference of each force until the twenty that are granted in this second level were completed. But at the regional level, candidates would not be comfortably elected through closed party lists, as now. Instead, the defeated candidates with the highest number of votes in the local districts would be elected, that is, the best defeated candidates. Thus, the candidates who, although defeated, would have contributed more votes to the common “bag” of votes used to assign representatives at this level would be rewarded.

The final result is that the disproportion would be reduced from 33% to 3.5%, and would turn the canary into one of the least disproportionate systems in the world. And we would also solve the problem of disconnection between voter and representative, responding to the cry of “they do not represent us”, certainly justified in our current electoral system.

social network

More news

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.