The worst among the mediocre

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 05/15/16.

This week the ISSUE Rankings (Synthetic Indicators of the Spanish University System) corresponding to the year 2016 were published. These rankings aim to generate classifications of Spanish universities based on extensive sets of information, which cover the three main dimensions of their activities: teaching, research and innovation and technological development. The ISSUE methodology is rigorous and is aligned with the recommendations of recent international reports on this subject. The rankings have been built from a set of variables that take into account the different missions of the universities: teaching, research, technological development and innovation. 

The ranking of universities shows significant differences in performance in Spanish universities, since the most productive ones double the results of those in the last positions. As an example, the first university in the ranking triples the performance of the last one. And this in a context that generally places our university system among the mediocre on an international scale. Thus, the quintessential ranking of universities, that of Shanghai, places only one Spanish university among the 200 best in the world, and only thirteen among the 500 best. These data are frequently mentioned as proof of the limited quality and limited international projection of our university system.

Within the general mediocrity in the performance and quality of the Spanish university, it is convenient to know what place the Canarian universities occupy. Given that the Government of the Canary Islands will allocate no less than 212 million euros in 2016 to finance university education in our archipelago, it is important to find out the return that this annual investment produces for our society, from which it is financed. What is the performance of our universities both in general and in teaching, research and technological development and innovation?

Regarding general performance, we started badly, since in the two Canarian universities it is 20% lower than the average and half of the best Spanish university (Pompeu Fabra). They are not the worst, but almost. Only six universities obtain worse performance in Spain, and of them five are private and the other (UNED) is distance learning. So it can be concluded that the Canary Islands are the worst face-to-face public universities in Spain. Quite an achievement. 

Regarding teaching, our performance is “only” 10% lower than the average and they are no longer the worst face-to-face public universities in Spain. Behind them, with a teaching performance 20% below the average, are the Universities of La Coruña, Burgos, Castilla-La Mancha, Extremadura and La Rioja. The mania for creating universities in almost every province seems to be behind the dismal results of these universities. That La Rioja, with barely three hundred thousand inhabitants and without enough population to sustain a quality university education, has created its own university is a paradigmatic example that we Spaniards seem to prefer mediocrity close to excellence.

In research, the performance of the University of La Laguna (ULL) is average (thank goodness), while that of the University of Las Palmas (ULPGC) is 20% below the average, which brings it, once again, to the worst position among face-to-face public universities in Spain.

Finally, in technological development and innovation, the results are truly disastrous. The performance of the ULPGC is 60% lower than the average and that of the ULL is 70% worse. The University of La Laguna holds the status of “red lantern” in this aspect among public and private, face-to-face and non-face-to-face universities. There is no other worse university, not even as bad, in all of Spain. Technological development and innovation measures the return to society in the form of R&D&I. To do this, it uses data on income from licenses, consulting contracts and continuing training; number of patents, commercialized patents, triadic (international) patents and income from international contracts. This is a fairly solid indicator that shows that this social return simply does not exist. If we take into account that Canarian R&D&I rests fundamentally and almost exclusively on our universities, we already know why our archipelago tops all Spanish statistics on innovation and technological development. This way we will never progress in the society of innovation and knowledge. 

The differences in productivity of universities are also seen at the regional level. Catalonia, Cantabria, the Valencian Community, Navarra, the Balearic Islands and Madrid are the communities that have the most productive university systems, with average levels higher than those of Spain as a whole. Extremadura, La Rioja and the Canary Islands have the worst university systems in Spain. The worst thing is that in the last year Extremadura and La Rioja have improved, while the Canary Islands maintain stable its low performance in that caboose.

Given that there does not seem to be even the slightest hint of reaction in the Canary Islands universities themselves regarding these dismal results, we will have to ask ourselves if our authorities should not take action on the matter. More than two hundred million euros a year of taxpayers (mis)spent demand it. How about financing linked to results? How about not financing grades with few students? Wouldn't it be appropriate to analyze whether our model of two full universities is wrong? How about specializing each one in what they do best? After all, excellence depends at least in part on selecting the best for each task. Otherwise, we will continue as before, with the worst universities in the already mediocre Spanish university system.

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.