Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 05/29/16.
Last week it was learned that the public debt in Spain had reached the psychological level of 100% of GDP, a level that had not been seen in our country since 1909, as a result of the debt caused by the disastrous wars of '98. The difference is that that year Spain was emerging from a crisis and reducing the debt. Now it's going up. As the debt became unpayable, to resolve the issue they ended up resorting to debt write-offs. The traditional alternative in Spain.
Go bankrupt and default on the debt, once again. Not in vain, the bankruptcy of finances is almost a Spanish historical tradition that has been repeated since the 16th century. Our country was the first to create bonds and also the first to stop paying them. We hold the world record for bankruptcies. No less than thirteen since Felipe II. The last one during the civil war, although eighty years have passed since then, and now, within the EU and converted into a “serious” country, it is not an option for Spain, except for some enlightened ones.
In Spain, the debt has gone from representing 36% of GDP in 2007 to exceeding 100% in 2016. This is not the only case in the euro zone, since other countries such as Greece (176.9%), Italy (132.7%), Portugal (129%), Belgium (106%) and Cyprus (108.9%) also exceed that limit. It goes without saying that Greece is de facto bankrupt and will never repay that debt, so sooner or later it will have to undergo a (hopefully orderly) debt restructuring. Of course, no one will lend it money again for decades, just as has been happening to Argentina since the bankruptcy of 2001. Italy exceeded 100% debt to GDP in 1992 and has never managed to reduce it from that figure. Portugal exceeded 100% in 2011 and now reaches 129%. It doesn't seem like he'll ever get out of that spiral either. None of these countries is a role model or part of the countries with the highest well-being in Europe.
What I'm trying to say is that reducing debt below 100% is very complicated. No country has been able to significantly and permanently reduce its debt without restructuring or default after having reached 100% of GDP, since this enormous debt forces a significant percentage of tax revenue to be allocated to pay its interest. Even in financing conditions as advantageous as the current ones due to the purchases of sovereign debt by the European Central Bank (ECB), paying the interest on the debt will cost Spain around 30-35 billion euros over the next few years. The purchase of debt by the ECB artificially reduces the risk premium and generates a misleading sense of tranquility. As soon as the ECB stops buying sovereign debt, the payment of these interests will escalate to around 40,000 million euros annually. That means that we should allocate a good bit of our taxes to pay interest for many years, which means that future fiscal policy will have to be even more restrictive and will reduce the rate of growth and job creation.
What the historical analysis of financial crises in the world during the last eight centuries says is that once public debt exceeds 80% of GDP it begins to have negative effects. There are those who think that Spain lives immersed in a climate of austerity, but nothing could be more false. An economy with a deficit of 5% of GDP when it grows at 3% is an economy that lives beyond its means.
The fact that a country goes into debt is not inherently negative. When that debt is used to invest in infrastructure that will generate income and future well-being, there is nothing wrong with getting into debt. After all, if our children and grandchildren will enjoy the hospitals, roads and educational centers that we build today, it is only fair that they collaborate in the future to pay for it. But public administrations are not going into debt to finance infrastructure, but rather current spending. In 2016, the public sector plans to invest 24 billion euros (2.2% of GDP) in infrastructure, while it will allocate 32 billion euros (2.9%) to satisfy debt interest and 30 billion euros (2.7%) to finance the structural pension deficit. The latter will grow inexorably and gradually in the next 20-30 years to 60,000 million euros (now) due to the aging of the population.
In the pre-election campaign, no one talks about how to reduce public debt when the accelerated aging of the population in Spain brings us closer to an unprecedented demographic crisis, which will cause health and pension expenses to multiply at the same time that a shrinking population is forced to repay an increasingly large debt. None of this is talked about because in Spain decisions are not made or reforms made when we grow up, which is when it is easier to digest them, but when we are on the brink of the abyss. The purchase of sovereign debt by the ECB, which reduces our interest payment to a digestible level, opens a small window of opportunity for Spain to free future generations from an unbearable burden, but I have not heard any political party commit to allocating excess income derived from high growth to reduce debt and not to current spending. Not to undertake new cuts, but simply to allocate the income derived from high growth to repay debts. On the contrary. Everyone promises to spend more and/or reduce taxes as if there were no tomorrow. And tomorrow is just around the corner. The number of deaths now exceeds the number of births in Spain for the first time. Spain will soon become the oldest country in Europe. Tomorrow is already here.
U!



