Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in Diario de Avisos on 04/27/2014.
The Bank of Spain (BdE) has just published statistics on household financial accounts for 2013, and newspaper headlines have been quick to highlight that “family wealth returns to the levels of 2006”, before the crisis. Indeed, the net financial wealth of Spanish households in 2013 reached the figure of 1,044 trillion, the highest in the entire historical series that began in 1980. Does this mean that Spanish families are once again rich, like before the crisis? It seems obvious that data like this in a depressive environment for many family economies, besieged by high levels of unemployment, falling salaries and voluminous outstanding debts, is shocking. To understand the reasons for such a paradox, it would be necessary to clarify clearly what the BdE is talking about when it refers to net financial wealth.
The first thing to highlight is that wealth is a stock made up of the value of all our assets, such as homes, vehicles, jewelry, art, checking accounts, pension plans, etc., while income is a flow made up of salaries, pensions, stock dividends, rental income and interest on checking accounts and deposits, mainly. It is perfectly possible to be “rich” (owner of valuable assets) and not be able to sustainably meet your most obvious needs due to a lack of recurring income. Many households own one or several valuable homes, but do not have income due to having lost their job and find themselves in this situation: they have possessions, but no income, and when they try to convert that supposed real estate wealth into money they discover that there are no buyers for their homes.
The second thing is that the BdE has published the net financial wealth statistics. Financial wealth is the difference between the value of the financial assets and the household's debts, but financial assets barely make up 20% of the total household assets, since most Spanish families have invested (wrongly, as I have already mentioned on many occasions) their money mainly in real estate, and the value of these has not stopped falling since 2007. Thus, what has returned to pre-crisis levels is not the total wealth, but the financial one. And no matter how much financial wealth has increased in 2013, it does not compensate for the drop in real estate values.
What this statistic tells us is that, when compared to 2012, the net financial wealth of Spanish households increased by no less than 213 billion euros. This spectacular increase has been the result of a reduction of 55,000 million in debt and an increase in assets of 158,000 million euros, as a result of the increase in the value of shares. Thus, it is very clear which families came out ahead in 2013: those who had money invested in stocks. It is not about new savings invested, since new investments in shares only grew by 8,000 million, but rather the impact of the 20% revaluation of the stock market during 2013. Obviously this fact leaves many families out of the eventual recovery: those who do not have money invested in the Stock Market.
If compared with the situation before the crisis, the financial wealth of households reached its minimum level in 2008, when the value of shares plummeted by 266 billion euros compared to 2006, and since 2008 wealth has not stopped growing, although supported by two pillars very different from the recent past: the reduction of debt among families and their greater willingness to save in cash and deposits, with a more conservative savings strategy. It is true that the stock market has recovered remarkably during 2013, but the value of shares held by households is still 21% below the pre-crisis level. On the other hand, the forced effort of austerity and spending containment that the economic crisis has brought with it has served to reinstate a culture of domestic economy that plans for the future beyond the day-to-day and avoids risk, but that stage has already been completed and should be followed by a return to a balanced and responsible family spending scheme and partly recovering investment in the stock market, with better profitability prospects than investment in deposits. That this happens and families see how the value of their assets grows is important due to the so-called “wealth effect”, a phenomenon that increases consumption and, consequently, production and employment, simply by believing oneself to be richer. But although the improvement in the value of financial assets can partly help the recovery of consumption, for this effect to help us get out of the crisis, we also need a stabilization of the real estate market, where households have invested most of their savings. Rich again? No. We would like to.



