Dark clouds on the horizon

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in the July 2018 issue of La Gaveta Económica.

Negative leading indicators have continued to accumulate in recent months, predicting dark clouds on the horizon.

At the international level, the incipient trade war between the United States and the rest of the world that is beginning to break out will cause problems for global economic growth. If something is clear in economic theory, it is that protectionism only brings short-term benefits for the protected sectors and short, medium and long-term damage for the rest of the sectors and for the economy and employment as a whole. One of the few differences between the depression of the 1930s and the Great Recession of 2008 is that in the latter, governments had at least avoided entering into a dynamic of trade wars that further deepened and lengthened the world economy during the 1930s. And then Trump arrived and decided to start trade hostilities, even though the American economy was enjoying an unemployment rate below 4% and a long period of prosperity. The result will be an escalation of retaliation from the rest of the countries towards the United States that will only end when the current occupant of the White House comes to his senses, which knowing the character may never be, or leaves the presidential chair, which will happen in 2020 at the earliest. Meanwhile, global economic growth will suffer, and employment with it.

The price of oil is not good either, and seems to stabilize between $75 and $80 per barrel, which for an economy heavily dependent on crude oil like the Spanish one is a burden. Its impact will begin to be felt from the third quarter of the year, but if one of the “tailwinds” for the Spanish economy had been the fall in the price of oil, that wind has shifted and is now hitting head-on.

The other external factor driving our growth, expansionary monetary policy, is also changing direction. Global financial conditions are becoming strained due to the departure of central banks and increases in long-term interest rates. The withdrawal of stimulus by central banks will leave markets more exposed to any shock, and the strong volatility in stock markets indicates that investors are beginning to discount that the era of abundant and cheap money is coming to an end, and predicts financial turbulence that never knows how it could end.

Whether these financial turbulences will end up affecting the euro again will be seen over time, but the arrival to power in Italy of a populist coalition exponentially increases the chances that this will end up being the case. From 2011 until now, the safety cushion of sovereign debt purchases by the European Central Bank (ECB) has functioned as a tension buffer for the financing of the public deficits of the southern European countries. But with a government in Italy unwilling to comply with a minimum budgetary discipline, the incentives for the ECB to continue purchasing debt are zero, and we must not forget that the ECB already owns more than 20% of the Spanish sovereign debt and currently acquires a third of the debt we issue. As soon as it stops doing so, the least bad thing that will happen will be that the cost of financing our deficit will increase substantially, which will force us to dedicate more resources to paying the debt. But in the worst case scenario, if distrust in Italy runs out of control and the ECB does not act as a fire extinguisher, the financing problems of our public debt suffered between 2010 and 2011 could be repeated.

In Spain, other leading indicators signal the end of the economic boom. Retail sales are about to enter negative year-on-year growth, tourism is no longer the engine of growth, and the industry is beginning to slow down. We must not forget that the Spanish economy has not made a single structural reform since 2015, and has wasted the years of prosperity experienced to achieve budget balance, improve work productivity, end duality and temporality in employment, or resolve the sustainability of the pension system, to name only the most pressing problems that have not been addressed during the last three years.

I have been saying for some time that an economy that grows around three percent for years and is unable to achieve budgetary balance in public finances is incapable of facing the slightest setback in the economic environment. With public debt exceeding 100% of GDP in Spain, a level not seen in our country since 1909, if the cost of debt financing rises from the current 1.5% not to unsustainable figures of 6%-7% as in 2011, but to perfectly reasonable figures of 3.5%-4%, our capacity for growth and job creation will be seriously affected. The truth is that under normal financing conditions no country has been able to significantly and permanently reduce its debt without restructuring or default after having reached 100% of GDP, since this enormous debt forces a significant percentage of tax revenue to be allocated to pay its interest. The purchase of sovereign debt by the ECB, which has been reducing our interest payments to a digestible level, opened a small window of opportunity for Spain to free future generations from an unbearable burden, an opportunity that has been squandered and that, I fear, has passed and will never return.

An economy with a deficit of 3% of GDP when it has grown at 3% for three years is an economy that lives beyond its means. In a favorable international environment, inaction does not have serious consequences, but as soon as the wind changes, unresolved problems come to the surface and complicated and, almost always, unpopular measures must be taken. I doubt that the new government will be able (or willing) to take them, but there will be no choice but to try to weather the storm. He chose a bad time to take control of the ship.

social network

More news

INFOREM COYUNTURA TURÍSTICA DE CANARIAS Y PERPECTIVAS 3T2026

Canary Islands Tourism Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.