Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 02/28/16.
Last Wednesday, February 24, PSOE and Ciudadanos signed the “Agreement for a reformist and progressive government.” In general, the agreement is coherent, moderate and centrist, with mutual concessions to facilitate consensus. It is an agreement that 75% of citizens could accept in most of its points, although few will share 100% of its content. I don't do it either, since I approve around 60% and detect some shortcomings, but it is an acceptable agreement for the sake of the necessary consensus.
Since, due to space problems, it is impossible to comment on all its aspects in this column, I will focus only on the labor issues that occupy a good part of the initial controversy. The first thing to say in this sense is that, no matter what the PSOE does, the 2012 labor reform of the PP fortunately is not repealed by any means. We economists must have done something wrong during the almost forty years of our democracy when we failed to make a good number of Spaniards understand that our labor relations system has been disastrous until Felipe González's reform in 1994, bad since then until the PP reform of 2012, and mediocre in recent years. As the preamble of the labor aspects in the Agreement itself indicates, "Spain has been the only OECD country in which the unemployment rate has exceeded 20% on up to three occasions since 1980. Furthermore, the percentage of temporary workers with respect to the total has been increasing progressively, until it significantly exceeds the EU average. Only from these figures could it be pointed out that the functioning of the labor market has been one of the great failures of our democracy." Repealing the 2012 reform would mean going back from a mediocre labor relations system to a bad one, the one that existed before that date, whose inflexibility regarding salaries and working hours led companies at the height of the crisis to adapt to the drop in sales in the only way they were allowed: by laying off workers or closing. And they laid off more than 3.5 million workers while increasing the salaries of those who remained employed by between 3% and 6%. Ridiculous and dramatic.
The repeal of the labor reform that the PSOE carried out in its program does not appear in the document. What the agreement includes are changes, such as the elimination of the priority of the company agreement over higher-level agreements with regard to the working day and base salary, the maintenance of the ultra-activity of the agreements during a renegotiation period of 18 months, the reduction to three types of contract (indefinite, internship and stable of limited duration), incentives for those companies that create stable employment through social contributions and penalties for those who abuse labor rotation, and the so-called “backpack”. “Austrian” to promote labor mobility.
Ciudadanos renounces the single contract as such, but rescues some of its characteristics in the stable contract of limited duration limited in time, with increasing severance payments, so the average compensation of temporary workers would increase. However, the document does not define causality in temporary hiring, which is the “mother of the lamb” to end the fraud of law by which many companies use temporary contracts for indefinite positions. Whether or not the reform reduces temporality will depend in part on how this causality is reflected in the legislation.
The maintenance of the ultra-activity of the agreements, that is, their indefinite validity until the signing of a new agreement, I consider to be a step backwards, since it goes back to the situation prior not to 2012, but to 2008, in which a privileged group of workers, generally employed in essential public services, could maintain sine die working conditions well above those of the market, extracted under pressure from the government in power, with the simple strategy of never reaching a new one. agreement that would reduce them. Air traffic controllers are the most relevant example of this practice, since, after achieving salaries of 350,000 euros in 1998 and the self-regulation of air traffic management and control in Spain, they refused to change a comma of the agreement, clinging to their ultra-activity.
The most innovative thing in the workplace is the introduction of incentives for social contributions based on temporality (bonus/malus) and the new fund to finance part of the cost of dismissal known as the “Austrian backpack”. Here you can see the hand of Ciudadanos. The regulation discourages companies that abuse excessive dismissals in stable contracts by increasing the unemployment social contributions that they must pay (malus), while at the same time it encourages (bonus) in contributions to those companies that dismiss less for this reason and that increase their percentage of indefinite contracts. On the other hand, a new fund is created (the Austrian “backpack”) that will be responsible for the payment of 8 days per year of seniority in severance pay. This “backpack” can be taken by workers to a new job, favoring labor mobility (disincentives to reject a better job offer so as not to lose the right to severance pay) or enjoy it in retirement if they are never fired. They are two very interesting and effective measures.
Spain needs a labor market that creates stable employment during expansionary phases, with a salary linked to the competitiveness of the company, and that in crises the necessary flexibility occurs in the form of reductions in salaries or hours and not only through layoffs, to prevent our unemployment rate from exceeding 20% in each crisis. This program would be one more step in that direction, but not the final solution, I'm afraid.



