The difficult estimation of seats in the next elections

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 11/22/15.

At Corporación 5 we have been conducting market research for more than eighteen years through our subsidiary SAO, and we are well aware of the difficulties of translating the estimate of votes into seats for general elections. At Corporación 5-SAO we have our own methodology to make electoral estimates. We use the poll aggregation technique to reduce the biases and errors introduced by the sampling methodology of each pollster, which allows us to reduce the volatility in the predictions, and substantially improve the predictions of the electoral results. Likewise, to reduce the systematic biases of each pollster, we work with the unadjusted data, weighting them according to the number of respondents, the proximity to election day and the success of the pollster in the past. With this methodology our vote estimate for the next general elections is the one shown in the attached table.

\"\"

As can be seen, in the last month the tendency to reduce the vote of the PP and PSOE continues, although in the latter party this trend is accentuated, losing 1.2 p.p. during the last thirty days. Likewise, Podemos continues its downward trend, although it is beginning to slow its rate of decline, losing one percentage point of vote estimates in the last month, when in the previous month it lost 1.6 p.p. Ciudadanos continues to grow in the polls after the Catalan elections of 27S, and is now less than four percentage points behind the PSOE. But what is new is the growth of IU, which will compete in the next elections in coalition with various parties and social movements under the acronym UP, which abandons a long trend of decline or stagnation in vote estimates and grows 0.4 percentage points.

After the publication of our October vote estimate, some readers asked me why we didn't make an estimate of seats along with the vote estimate. And my answer is that it was risky and not serious to do it with the data we had. And I explain why. In our current electoral system for Congress, 350 deputies are elected in 50 electoral districts that coincide with the province, so to make reliable estimates of the number of seats, electoral simulations must be carried out in each of the fifty provinces, since the percentage of votes necessary to obtain a seat in each of them is very different. It happens that in Spain the distribution of seats by province is very unequal and, in a very summary way, it amounts to establishing a distribution in three parts. 117 deputies (33% of the total) are awarded by the six most populated provinces (in which more than ten seats are contested), 129 (36%) by the eighteen medium-sized provinces (those that distribute between six and ten seats), and 104 (30%) by the twenty-six small provinces, Ceuta and Melilla (which distribute five seats or less). This distribution of seats is not carried out in a completely proportional manner, but rather, before allocating the seats according to the population, two “gift” deputies are assigned to each province (and one to Ceuta and Melilla). This means that 102 deputies are distributed equally among the constituencies for territorial reasons and not in proportion to their population. 

In this way, only 248 deputies are distributed equally according to the population, which is already a reason why an estimate of seats proportional to the vote cannot be made. Sparsely populated provinces are overweighted in the allocation of seats and with relatively few votes (20,000 or even less) you can obtain a seat in them that costs four times more in the case of large provinces. But the fundamental reason is the number of votes that are wasted in small and medium-sized provinces without obtaining representation. Thus, for example, if Ciudadanos obtains that 18.2% of the votes evenly distributed in all constituencies, it could only aspire to obtain representation in the provinces that distribute four or more seats, which would deprive it of contesting seats in eleven provinces. Podemos would have it even worse, since with that percentage it would only obtain representation in the provinces that distribute five or more seats, which leaves it out of the game (and from the distribution of 30% of the total seats) in no less than twenty provinces. To complicate things even more, it is unrealistic to think that the party vote is distributed evenly throughout all provinces. Some are socially more “right” and others “left”, some are very nationalist (which introduces other parties into the “game”) and others not at all, etc. And with national surveys of around 1,000 interviews, although it is feasible to estimate the national vote if the sample is well selected, it is impossible to make informed estimates of the vote by province. The only pollsters that can currently carry out these estimates are those that carry out their own surveys on a recurring basis (weekly, biweekly or, at most, monthly) since, again thanks to the aggregation of surveys, they have a sample that is sufficiently representative of the vote by province.

For our part, despite all these inconveniences, we will be able to make an estimate of seats in our next estimate for the month of December, since at that time we will already have several national surveys with representative samples by province (that of the CIS for next month and some more), as well as numerous regional surveys that are being published and will be published in the near future. This, together with the aggregate estimate of votes, will allow us to estimate seats. Another thing would be to use the crystal ball, which is something we don't do.

social network

More news

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.