
In an interview with DIARIO DE AVISOS, the president of the Provincial Confederation of Businessmen of Santa Cruz de Tenerife (CEOE-Tenerife) spoke about the uncertain economic future of the Archipelago, the “magical” budgets prepared by the Canary Islands Government and immigration policy.
During the third quarter of 2020, the consequences of Covid-19 have generated a negative impact on the economy, which is unprecedented. The health effects, the declaration of the state of alarm, restrictions on mobility, the closure of borders and the complete paralysis of some economic activities have generally affected the entire development of the economy and society worldwide. All of this has led us to live during these eight months in a state of permanent uncertainty: the worst enemy of companies. What's more, the president of the Provincial Confederation of Entrepreneurs of Santa Cruz de Tenerife (CEOE-Tenerife) advises getting used to living with it [uncertainty] because waiting for a "perfect, laboratory model will only prolong the agony." In an interview with DIARIO DE AVISOS, José Carlos Francisco spoke about the uncertain economic future of the Archipelago, the “magical” budgets prepared by the Canary Islands Government and immigration policy.
-All organizations point to a fall in the Canary Islands economy. You estimate that the collapse will be 24%. How do we get out of this?
"Well, look, I don't know. I wish I knew! It is true that the forecasts of all the institutes and economic organizations continue to worsen, which indicates that the expectations about the duration and depth of the crisis were too optimistic. As time goes by, we are realizing that the crisis is going to last longer than we thought and that the exit from the tunnel is further away. But the worst thing is that by the end of the year, it is most likely that these forecasts that we gave on Friday in the report “The situation will be worse.”
-You proposed three possible scenarios after the pandemic. Are we entering the most pessimistic one?
"Very pessimistic, yes. Look, the issue here is that the forecasts are not based on economic data but on health estimates. So when you ask an economist how things are going, things depend on how the virus goes. In this environment, the economist is unable to predict anything so it is quite likely that he will be wrong. Look, the crisis of 1970 had an economic cause: the rise in oil; there have been crises due to rising interest rates, industrial ones, due to lack of liquidity in the market, due to the bursting of the real estate bubble... All of them for economic reasons. Not now. What has happened is that there is a virus and the economy has closed.
-Will the lifting of travel restrictions by our main markets such as Germany and the United Kingdom and the new Government decree that requires tourists to have negative tests to stay at the hotel give the tourism sector a break? Will more tourists come now?
"I think we must do everything possible to improve things and the tests are a step forward, but let's not fool ourselves, it is absolutely insufficient, because what is behind people not traveling is not the tests, the problem is that: a) they are afraid; b) they are not satisfied with traveling in the current conditions; and c) disposable income is lower. These three factors are what make people not travel now. Then there are the people who, once these three factors have been overcome, want to travel and that is why the tests are good for them. We have to put them in place to ensure these tourists and that, at least, the hotels that remain open do not close.”
-How can the Canary Islands survive a winter season with 20% or 30% occupancy?
"Well, very bad. Let's not forget, furthermore, that there are more than 80,000 people in the Canary Islands who are not really working although they have not lost the contractual relationship with their company, and who earn less, but they do get paid. This is being endured now, but it can be endured for a while. The health solution has to come at some point because if not it is impossible to continue to endure."
-The World Tourism Organization said last week that there will be no tourism recovery until 2024?
"If I'm honest, I'm not able at this time to make a forecast of tourist arrivals for next year. With scenarios of assumptions, yes, but as freely as the Government said last week, which also said that 10 million tourists would arrive this year, no. The normal thing is that figures similar to those of 2019 will not occur until 2023, but it is difficult."
-And in the meantime? Blood, sweat and tears?
"Of course: blood, sweat and tears, because during this period there will be many companies that cancel and close permanently. But look, I am aware that I don't know, and the reason is that we have never experienced a crisis of this type. In the previous one we were able to announce what was going to happen, when we were going to recover the level of GDP, the level of per capita income,... Now I am incapable because my econometric models are worthless because I don't have the most important thing involved: covid 19. Almost virologists are the ones who now have the greatest ability to predict. We have no experience of similar situations.”
-Is the Reactiva Plan the solution?
"I insist. All help is good. The ERTE are a mechanism to help workers and families above all. And the ICOs are a liquidity instrument for companies. They are two great measures that, obviously, have helped. But what happens? Well, they are going to have to be extended because on January 31 there will be many sectors that will still not open. And the same thing happens with the ICOs. There will be many companies that in March will be unable to return the loans so the period will have to be extended. waiting period for one more year. This plan and the European funds help, but the injection of this money will begin to be noticeable by 2020 or 2023. Look, what is happening is so serious that any measure adopted is insufficient And, furthermore, those that are necessary such as ICOs or ERTE cannot last indefinitely. Other regions with less dependence on the service sector see the exit closer or the fall not so deep.”
-Do they miss more measures from the administration?
"What I miss most is that the ERTE were designed for a situation in which the exit was supposed to be in a V, that is, the economy fell a lot, but rebounded quickly and that is why companies, under this premise, committed to maintaining employment. Now that it has been seen that the exit is not going to be in a V, maintaining this in the current ERTE is deceiving ourselves. Companies now cannot commit to maintaining the workforce six months after entering an ERTE because they will not to have a demand the same as what they had before the crisis began. To this we must add postponing the lack of ICOs and prolonging the ERTE. It is also essential to work for administrative simplification so that all the projects that come out do so quickly. Now construction has a leading role and may be, for a time, the one that takes over from tourism.
-Can the Canary Islands become a subsidized region?
"It is possible that this will happen for one or two years, but it is not something sustainable over time. Nobody is going to subsidize us forever."
-Have you had time to see the regional budgets? How is it possible that social spending increases with less income?
"I haven't had time. You have to study them well, but it increases personnel costs by 8%, investment by 17%, it doesn't raise taxes and there is no debt: it seems like a magical budget. Too good to be true."
-What do you think that at a time like the current one, the hospitality unions demand the salary increase agreed in the agreement?
"Well, they haven't understood anything. Look, we have been talking throughout the interview that the situation is serious and the hardest since the Spanish Civil War. There are no economic solutions; and having said all this, we do three cartwheels in the air and the hospitality union, the sector most affected by the crisis, arrives and asks for a wage increase. If this debate goes anywhere, it is because we have not understood anything at all. If we do not understand the situation in which we are all in the slightest, we are not going anywhere. And the same thing happens with the officials.”
-Another of the big problems we are facing is illegal immigration. How do we solve it taking into account that the State and Europe do nothing?
"Well, I'm glad that you brought this matter up with me because it's time to talk clearly about this issue. It's true that we are still far from reaching the cayuco crisis, but it has all the earmarks of being a rebound. Do you know what the problem is? Well, the migration problem is being treated without taking into account the situation we are in, that is, we are treating the entry of illegal immigrants just like in 2004, and we don't realize that Europe has closed its borders due to Covid. "We have not realized that there is an international crisis and we are acting as if the virus did not exist."
-And what is the solution?
"I don't know. What I do know is that at the moment continuing with the current immigration policy does not work because other countries are not applying it. That is why I say that it would be appropriate, without passion, to put the figures on the table. So far this year, in the Canary Islands the entry of illegal immigrants has increased by 688% and in the Peninsula it has decreased by 29%. Why do you think this is due? The routes have changed. All of Europe has its borders closed due to the virus, less the Canary Islands. I don't know if it is due to goodness or misunderstood altruism, but it has been proven that the same immigration policy that in 2004 does not work in the current situation, because, in addition, Europe does the opposite: it has its borders closed due to Covid and does not allow transfers from the Canary Islands.
-You are aware that these types of statements can generate rejection.
"They may not, they generate rejection. Look, the solution to the immigration problem has to come from Europe, not the Canary Islands."



