Inequality and poverty

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 06/12/16.

“28.6% of Spaniards are at risk of poverty and social exclusion,” most Spanish newspapers published on their front pages less than a month ago. “In Spain there are 13 million poor people,” said others. This data is obtained from the Living Conditions Survey (ECV) prepared by the INE and using the AROPE methodology (from English, at risk of poverty or social exclusion). But are there really 13 million people who are poor or at risk of being poor in Spain? I can already tell you that, if we use the concept of poverty that a citizen understands, it will be no. First of all, let's define what we are talking about.

“Poor” according to the Royal Spanish Academy (RAE) is someone “in need, who does not have what is necessary to live.” And what is necessary to live? Anyone would say that healthy food, decent housing, energy, water, health and education. Is that what the AROPE methodology measures? No. The majority of people classified as below the poverty line according to this methodology come from having an income of less than 60% of the median income in Spain. That is, the poverty threshold thus defined depends on what others earn. Queer. In Spain, in 2015 the median income was 13,352 euros and, therefore, the poverty threshold was established at 8,011 euros, a threshold that was not reached by 22.1% of Spaniards. Interestingly, as income grew during 2015, so did the poverty line. 

It doesn't make much sense, especially when this index is later used to make international comparisons. What does it mean that the poverty rate is similar in two countries whose per capita incomes are extremely different? Will it not mean that the poorest in the richest country have much more than the richest in the poor country? A “poor person” in Spain has 20 years more life expectancy and ten times more income than a “poor person” in a medium-developed country (let alone an underdeveloped country). In fact, a person with an income of 8,000 euros (a little below the poverty line in Spain) would be among the 10% of people with the highest income in the world, even taking into account their purchasing power with it. That's nothing, a “poor person” in Switzerland is among the 1% of people with the highest income in the world. As an indicator of poverty it is a disaster. What happens is that churras are being mixed with merinos with that definition of poverty. The fact that 22.1% of Spaniards have an income less than 60% of the median speaks to us about inequality in the distribution of income, not poverty. The distinction is important because the measures appropriate to reduce inequality are not the same as those that reduce poverty. Poverty and inequality are different, although related, phenomena. In general, greater inequality usually implies higher levels of poverty, but an egalitarian society can still have high poverty rates.

What would then be the number of poor people in Spain, of needy people, who do not have what they need to live, according to the definition of the RAE? The INE itself publishes in that same ECV survey an indicator called the severe material deprivation index, which is close to what anyone could understand by poverty. This is an index that is defined by the lack of at least four of the nine concepts listed below. A person has severe material deficiencies when they cannot afford: 1º At least one week of vacation a year. 2º A meal of meat, chicken or fish at least every two days. 3º Maintain the home with an adequate temperature. 4º Face unforeseen expenses (650 euros). 5º You have had delays in the payment of expenses related to the main home (mortgage or rent, gas bills, community...) or in installment purchases in the last 12 months. 6th Automobile. 7th Telephone. 8th Television. 9th Washing machine.

Some may be debatable. In my opinion, not being able to go on vacation for a week does not imply poverty, and having a television does not seem like a fundamental need to me either, but I think the index is much closer to what we are looking for. Well, in 2015 in Spain 6.4% of the population (just under three million people) suffered from severe material deprivation, that is, they suffered from at least four of these deficiencies. There are not a few people. On the contrary, it is a very high number, but it is not those 13 million that the headlines proclaimed. The maximum was reached a year before (2014), with 7.1% of the population and the minimum in 2007, before the crisis, when 3.5% of people suffered from severe material deficiency. Going into detail, in 2015 2.6% of people (1.2 million) could not afford a meal of meat, chicken or fish at least every two days. That is poverty. In 2014 this percentage was 3.3% and the minimum was reached in 2009 with 2.1% of people in this situation.

The main cause of inequality in the distribution of income in Spain is unemployment. 80% of the increase in inequality in income distribution during the crisis in Spain is due to the increase in unemployment, so reducing unemployment would reduce inequality to a large extent. But growth can only be pro-poor if the policies to boost it are part of a comprehensive package of measures to eradicate poverty. In Spain, poverty is “inherited” and passes from parents to children. Someone who was born poor has a high probability of living and dying in poverty. And it is this vicious circle that must be broken with specific measures. Precisely the number of children and their level of education are the factors that most influence ending up in poverty. Therefore, if inequality will reduce as employment improves, measures to support children and improve training are needed to reduce poverty. Let them apply.

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.