Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in the June 2018 issue of La Gaveta Económica.
After spending more than 45,000 million euros on the AVE in addition to 12,000 million euros more programmed for the coming years, little is said about the public utility of such an investment.
Spain is the European country with the largest high-speed railway network and in the entire world only China exceeds our 2,515 kilometers in service. According to a FEDEA study by Llobet and Betancor published in 2015, the current network has so far cost each Spaniard 1,071 euros, compared to the 461 that the Germans have paid for theirs, almost 700 for the French, and nearly 1,200 for each Japanese. Quite different is the use that travelers make of the service, a ranking in which Spain occupies the last place in the classification. In 2017, the AVE transported 21.1 million passengers in Spain, a historical record, while, with an inferior road network, Japan transported 330 million (fifteen times more) and France 125 million (six times more). For every operational kilometer there are 8,400 passengers in Spain, very far from the 61,400 in France, and a astronomical distance from the 158,121 in Japan. And the Spanish commitment to high speed continues with the recently presented State Budget project for 2018, where the main focus of public investment once again focuses on the railways, whose allocation increases by 22% to reach 3,727 million euros, of which the lion's share, 2,700 million euros, is reserved for the AVE.
In a country like ours, where it seems that money falls from the sky and where the social and financial profitability of investment projects is not usually seriously and rigorously evaluated, it is a rare occurrence to debate the social usefulness of public investments. Nobody seems to take into account that investing in some projects is done at the cost of not doing so in others (what in economics is known as opportunity cost), since money is not infinite, and it is reasonable to do so in those projects that are most profitable from a social point of view.
The study on the FEDEA AVE is devastating. In terms of social costs and benefits (including time savings, pollution, accidents, etc.), no high-speed AVE line should have been built in Spain. They are all socially deficient. The line that presents the best results is the Madrid-Barcelona, whose social benefits would barely cover 80% of the social cost of the investment in 50 years. In the case of the Madrid-Andalusia line, only 45% of the social cost would be recovered in that period; 43% in Madrid-Levante, and only 19% in Madrid-Northern Spain. In the latter, the expected social income does not even compensate for the variable operating costs, so keeping it open will mean an annual hemorrhage of public money, so it would be advisable to close it, considering the investment lost. The rest of the lines, once they are built, should remain operational since the operational social benefits exceed the costs, although not enough to recover and compensate for the investment made.
Despite this, the 2018 budgets will bury an additional 2.7 billion euros in new socially deficient AVE lines. And our infrastructure policy is dominated by engineering, with absolute neglect of the economy. It is a policy based on the idea that bigger and faster is better. We have assumed that any investment is capable of generating benefits, material or social, but the truth is that not all investments are socially profitable and that, prioritizing, the most socially profitable ones should be executed first, and not those with the greatest potential political benefit (in the form of votes).
The solution is not to invest in anything, but to evaluate the projects with technical criteria and with a serious and rigorous study of the different alternatives, to really know which is the best. In “serious” countries such as the United States, France and the United Kingdom, these evaluations are not only mandatory, but are subject to external review by project evaluation offices, in order to guarantee the quality of the study. A good cost-benefit analysis not only shows the benefits of each project and discovers its defects, which can be corrected and improved before making the investment, but also makes transparent and objective the way investments are made and who wins and loses with each action.
It would not be bad if a similar policy were implemented in Spain. Otherwise, in the future, what happened in 2009 during the visit of the US Secretary of Transportation will continue to happen to us, when he was asked why the US did not have a High Speed network like the Spanish one: “because we can't afford it,” he answered. Well that. To continue (mis)spending.



