DISAPPOINTING TAX REFORM

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in Diario de Avisos on 06/29/14.

The Government has presented several draft reforms of the personal income tax (IRPF), Companies (IS) and General Tax Law, which together it calls "Tax Reform" and which is now beginning its processing in the Cortes Generales for approval before the end of the year. After a year and a half of announcements and the report of a Commission of Experts, the result could not have been more disappointing. It should not even be called tax reform, since it amounts to little more than the reversal (partial, of course) of the 2012 personal income tax increase.

If compared to the current situation, all recipients of income from work benefit because in the first payroll of 2015 they will see how their withholdings are reduced and their net salary increases compared to the current one. The “timing” is not coincidental since 2015 is the year of local, regional and general elections and the reform has a great electoral “smell”. With this reform, all ranges of labor income, and especially low and medium income, will pay less in 2015 than in 2014. But if compared to 2011, not all incomes benefit, since despite the reductions in tax rates, various deductions are modified in such a way that, in the case of a taxpayer without children, only citizens with a gross payroll of less than 31,000 euros will pay less in 2015 for personal income tax than in 2011, while the others will pay more. It could not be any other way because while the increase in collection from the 2012 personal income tax increase was about 6,000 million euros, the reduction in 2015 will be about 4,500 million. Those 1.5 billion euros of difference have to be paid by someone, and those are medium-high and high incomes.

In general terms, the reform does not incorporate most of the recommendations of the Committee of experts (the so-called Lagares Report), which was going in the right direction. That report proposed lowering rates in personal income tax and corporations, now among the highest in the European Union; the greater weight of property taxes, now among the lowest in Europe; simplification of the tax system (fewer deductions and lower rates); and the increase in VAT and reduction in social contributions to promote job creation. The rate reduction occurs, but deductions are not eliminated, nor are property taxes, social contributions, or even VAT, except for some medical products that were required by a European ruling. If you are not going to pay attention to a group of experts that proposes an in-depth tax reform for more efficient and equitable taxation, why are they in charge of anything?

A multitude of studies have shown that it is more efficient to get more people to pay and to pay for all income, regardless of its origin, than to modify only the nominal rates. To do this, practically all of the deductions that reduce personal income tax collection by more than 15,000 million euros would have to be eliminated, as proposed by the Lagares Report. But only a few are eliminated, although new ones are introduced. More recommendations not assumed. The Committee of Experts also proposed eliminating the module regime for entrepreneurs, which has proven to be a source of tax fraud, and the Government only slightly limits it. The Lagares Report also proposed eliminating work income in kind (another source of fraud) and these are maintained. Especially flagrant is the immobility regarding property taxation. The experts proposed taxing real estate assets through a national Real Estate Tax (IBI). The tax rates would be applied to the market value of the properties, instead of the cadastral value. It would have been an equitable measure because those with a greater capacity to pay usually have more real estate assets, and efficient because collection would not be affected by its tax increase, since real estate cannot be taken out of the country or hidden, like other assets, since they are inventoried. None of this is touched.

Regarding savings income, the experts proposed significantly reducing the maximum exempt amount allocated to pension plans, since its high amount favors high incomes. Who else can't invest 833 euros per month in a product locked until retirement! Well, the Government reduces this limit only from 10,000 to 8,000 euros. Now taxpayers with incomes greater than 60,000 euros will “only” save 3,700 euros in taxes instead of 4,700. What progress in tax equity. The Lagares Report proposed avoiding banking intermediation for small savers by creating a savings account (the “Sicav for the poor”) from which small savers could invest their money in any asset without paying taxes until reimbursed. This too has come to nothing. In exchange, the Treasury has invented a type of guaranteed deposit or account (Savings Plans 5) whose interest will be tax-free if maintained for five years, but which will have to be managed by banks or insurers, and which financial entities will use to make it cheaper to attract liabilities by offering low returns and high commissions, just as they have been doing with Pension Plans. A favor to banks and insurance companies. Taking into account that the maximum annual contribution will be 5,000 euros, with a minimum 85% insured capital the profitability will not be much, so the tax savings will be very limited. With 5,000 euros at a 3% profitability (which would already be high) we would obtain 150 euros gross of interest, and we would save a whopping 28.50 euros in taxes by not declaring the 19% tax rate on savings. I don't doubt that there are those who "bite" and immobilize their savings for five years in exchange for 28 euros, but considering this product as an incentive to save seems like a joke. When workers are forced to look for high-yield assets to complement their meager future pension, it is unlikely that the Government would leave the assets with higher yields out of the Savings Plans 5.

In short, a reform that is not such and they go... and the current Government is specializing in leaving all its reforms half done and limiting itself to patching: labor, banking, administration, education, pensions and now tax. Whoever comes after the elections will have to reform everything again to balance the accounts again. What a wasted legislature.

social network

More news

INFOREM COYUNTURA TURÍSTICA DE CANARIAS Y PERPECTIVAS 3T2026

Canary Islands Tourism Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.