How many autonomies are necessary?

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 05/01/16.

What criteria does the current autonomous map respond to? Let's say it clearly: none. How was it made? Without previously establishing any rational design, but taking into account political conveniences, fixes and behind-the-scenes agreements. It was done in a haphazard manner and without the slightest rigor. The logical thing would have been to establish a basic general criterion that would take into account, not fantastic origins, feelings, essences or historical rights, but rather objective elements such as geography, language and the number of inhabitants, establishing a minimum population that would guarantee a certain efficiency in the provision of public services, which, after all, is what the autonomous communities (CCAA.) are dedicated to.

How can we justify today the existence of single-provincial communities such as La Rioja, Murcia, Asturias, Cantabria or Navarra, alongside others such as Castilla y León or Andalusia? The current autonomous map should be replaced by a more rational, more balanced one, which responds to objective criteria such as the improvement of public services, stimulation of productive development and better administrative organization. A technically justified reform but that also seeks equality for all citizens in access to education, health, work and communications.

How many CC.AA. are necessary? 17 is too many. Germany has 16 with a 75% larger population, and numerous studies carried out in the Bavarian country propose reducing them even further. In Brazil, the average population per region is 7.3 million on average; in the United States, 6.2 million; in South Africa, 5.6 million; and in Germany, 5.1 million inhabitants per territory. Spain has about 2.8 million inhabitants per autonomous community, but it should be close to the ratio of Germany. The multiplicity of CC.AA. with small populations generates extra costs in their operating expenses and, what is worse, multiplies the number of regulations to comply without being justified by the small number of inhabitants governed. The logical thing would be to impose a minimum population and mark new boundaries for the regions, reducing them, in order to rationalize costs, services and new functions, thus eliminating a monstrous bureaucracy and the consequent waste. 

A reduction in the number of regions would have three very positive effects: a) Firstly, it would mean a notable decrease in public spending. The structural spending of the State would decrease. The same thing (and probably better) would be done with less money, something essential to ensure the stability of public finances. b) The suppression would mean a notable simplification of the functioning of the State, in general, and of the bodies and institutions of cooperation and integration. It is easier to agree on ten or twelve than on seventeen. c) And from a political point of view, the suppression of those communities that were not based on an authentic social demand for self-government would reinforce the identity of the regions in which this demand is real. Not in vain, in ten Autonomous Communities citizens prefer less autonomy to the current situation. In short, with this reduction we would achieve a cheaper, more efficient and more inclusive State. 

Regarding the first point, if the operating expenses (personnel expenses and current expenses on goods and services) of the Spanish Autonomous Communities are analyzed, it is observed that the Autonomous Communities with a population of less than or close to one million inhabitants have higher operating expenses per inhabitant (2,100 euros per inhabitant). These higher expenses represent an extra cost of around 20% over the national average in the cost of providing public services (€1,750). The Autonomous Communities with a population between 1.3 and 2.8 million inhabitants show an operating expense per inhabitant (€1,725/inhabitant) around the average (€1,750/inhabitant). Finally, the Autonomous Communities with more than 5 million inhabitants have a per capita expenditure of €1,500, which is 14% less than the average. 

That is to say, if all the Autonomous Communities had more than five million inhabitants, total operating expenses would be reduced by around 11.5 billion euros per year, with service provision equal to or better than the current one. This figure is greater than the cuts in health and education implemented in 2012 by the Popular Party government, but in this case the savings would not be made at the cost of a reduction in the level of public services. Even more important would be the economic impact of the reduction in the number of autonomous regulations (and the added unnecessary complexity) that the grouping of Autonomous Communities would entail. Evidently there are geographical circumstances (the island fact in the Balearic Islands and the Canary Islands) and even historical sentiment (Navarra, the Basque Country), which advise maintaining a self-government regime for regions with a population of less than five million inhabitants, but many of the current Autonomous Communities were artificially created starting in 1978, for the interests of their elites, without a real demand for self-government from their populations behind them. Even with these exceptions, the annual savings in operating expenses would be around €9 billion.

How should the regions be regrouped? Anyone would say that taking into account economic, geographical and historical aspects, but the specificity is what would unleash passions since the history of our regions has intertwined one with the other on numerous occasions. But the important thing would be to get as close as possible to a ratio of 4-5 million inhabitants per region on average, as proposed by efficiency studies. These ratios would take us to about 10-12 regions, which would basically be achieved by integrating the uniprovincial Autonomous Communities into larger ones. A potential saving of 9,000 million euros per year does not seem negligible enough to ignore.

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.