oxygen balloon

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 04/24/16.

The Government of Spain has asked Brussels to postpone the fiscal consolidation of the public administration deficit for one year. Thus, from a planned deficit of 2.8% of GDP in 2016, it has gone up to 3.6%. These eight tenths are distributed between the Autonomous Communities (CCAA), whose red numbers may rise this year to 0.7% of GDP, instead of 0.3%, and Social Security, whose planned budget hole rises to 1.1%.

This relaxation in the path of budgetary consolidation represents a lifeline for the Autonomous Communities since, with the new objective, the regions will have to make an adjustment of about 7,000 million euros instead of the 14,000 million initially established. In relative terms, the effort consists of going from last year's deficit of 1.66% of GDP to 0.7%. This reduction in the red numbers would not have to entail additional adjustments for the regions, since it is expected that this year they will receive an additional 7,400 million euros on account of the 2014 budget settlement, as well as that they will benefit from extraordinary savings as the State "subsidizes" some 3,000 million euros of interest on the new debt issued under the Autonomous Liquidity Fund (FLA) set up by the State to get the CC.AA. of bankruptcy. So in practice they will have about 3.4 billion euros for additional spending although, having analyzed their spending intentions, it is likely that they will still fail to meet the new deficit target for another year.

And, in terms of non-compliance with the deficit objective of the Autonomous Communities, it rains in the wet. Last month, the European Commission sent a warning to the Spanish government due to the risk of non-compliance with the 2016 deficit, as a preliminary step to more severe coercive measures if the imbalances are not corrected. In this alert, Brussels criticizes with special emphasis the continuous budget imbalances of the autonomous communities (CCAA), which the Government does not put a stop to. Throughout the crisis, the majority of the Autonomous Communities (with honorable exceptions, among which the Canary Islands stand out) have exceeded the deficit limits set by the Government year after year, and in most cases due to a manifest lack of political will. The State Government, through the powers that the Organic Law on Budgetary Stability and Financial Sustainability of 2012 entrusts to it, has more than enough competence and powers to control the deficit of the Autonomous Communities and impose preventive, corrective and coercive measures if they do not do so, but the truth is that it does not exercise them. Because?

Basically because the Government of Spain and the Ministry of Finance are guided in their actions by criteria of political opportunity. And this has happened whether the non-compliant region is governed by the PP or by another political party. In the first case, it does not act because they are not going to amend the plans of “theirs”, and in the second case, because in the best of cases it would immediately become a full-fledged political attack by a party against its rival, and in the worst in an aggression by Spain against (for example) Catalonia. Thus, given the political effects that its actions would cause, the Government is politically, if not legally, incapable of using the coercive mechanisms provided for in the Budgetary Stability Law against the Autonomous Communities, despite the repeated, manifest and voluntary non-compliance with the deficit objectives of some of them. 

For this reason, the ability to take preventive, corrective and coercive measures against any public administration cannot be entrusted, as now, to the Ministry of Finance, but to the Independent Authority for Fiscal Responsibility (AIREF, what a great name), an independent entity for supervising the budgetary policies of public administrations created at the request of the European Union, with the explicit mandate of evaluating the macroeconomic forecasts that underlie the budgets of the administrations and the degree of compliance with national and supranational fiscal rules. It would therefore be necessary to modify the Organic Law so that the AIREF would be the one to establish the deficit objectives of each public administration, as well as to reconvene, accept and/or reject the budget balance plans carried out by the sub-state entities, instead of the Ministry of Finance. The Independent Fiscal Responsibility Authority would act as a neutral entity outside the political game, so that political convenience would cease to be a factor and the activity of supervising budgetary stability in public administrations would gain credibility...and effectiveness.

Given the importance of the powers entrusted to it, its election mechanism should be modified, in such a way that it was not the Ministry of Finance that proposed its top person, although until now there is no doubt about the independence of its management, even with harsh criticism of the Ministry of Finance. In any case, to reinforce this independence, its President should be elected by a three-fifths majority of the Congress of Deputies and the Senate for a period longer than the legislature (between six and ten years), from a shortlist proposed among its members by the Body of State Economists. Those who at some point in their lives had been elected officials, members of the Government, autonomous governments or senior officials of public administrations could not belong to this shortlist. With this appointment, it would be a matter of beginning the healthy British custom of completely separating the political career from the public service, as well as allowing the career in the public service to allow access to the most relevant positions of a technical nature. Another day I will expand on this matter.

social network

More news

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.