Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 05/24/15.
The French economist Esther Duflo has just won the Princess of Asturias Award for Social Sciences for her studies on development economics. Duflo has received numerous awards and distinctions for his work in experimental microeconomics, a discipline that seeks simple and practical answers from the observation of specific everyday problems.
Duflo believes that politicians are captive to the ambition of trying to solve the problem of poverty all at once. The battle against poverty can be won by respecting three conditions: patience, rigorous work and learning from empirical evidence. The role of economists when analyzing this problem should consist, on the one hand, of identifying and proposing concrete solutions and, on the other, of evaluating their application in a rigorously scientific manner. In this sense, she advocates the random evaluation of development aid policies, a methodology that the Poverty Action Laboratory (J-PAL), created by her and two other MIT economists, applies systematically. He insists on economics as a true human science. It involves choosing a reference population, applying a given policy to a randomly chosen group (the “treated group”) and leaving another group untreated (the “control group”). This method, common in medicine, was uncommon in economics until about 20 years ago. Randomization allows the mean treatment effect to be estimated simply by calculating the difference between the mean result of the treated group and the mean result of the control group. And it is achieved without the need for a theoretical model of the effect of interest and with few assumptions, although one must be very careful in the design and execution of the experiment.
This line of research has been very successful: in 2005, 67 of the 89 programs that the World Bank had in Africa were experimentally evaluated. One of its effects has been to divert resources from megaprojects to more modest but potentially very effective projects. For example, in a study about Kenya, Miguel and Kremer found that medicating children so that they do not have parasites (worms) is 20 times more effective in getting them to go to school than hiring another teacher.
According to Duplo, it is most likely that there is no single factor that causes poverty and there is no point in looking for the philosopher's stone that will solve it in one fell swoop. The most reasonable thing is to try different interventions and evaluate them consistently. Thus, we build a corpus of evidence that allows us to discern what works and what does not.
For example, regarding the problem of feeding the poor, he reaches surprising conclusions. Most people, even the poorest, earn enough money to afford an adequate diet, since calories are usually quite cheap, except in extreme situations (displaced people, wars). But when very poor people are able to spend a little more money on food, they do not seem to want more food, even though this would make their lives and those of their children better. Instead, they use part of that money to combat boredom (buying a television or organizing a party), and another part on food, but not to get more calories, but to buy tastier (and more expensive) but less nutritious foods. They could consume more calories and other nutrients if they spent less on expensive grains (such as rice and wheat), sugar, and convenience foods and more on leafy vegetables and coarse grains. But eating exclusively vegetables is boring.
Generally speaking, things that make life less boring (TV, sugar, parties) are a priority for the poor. They focus on the here and now, on living life in the most pleasant way possible, taking advantage of the (few) opportunities that are offered to them. They behave as if any change significant enough to merit the sacrifice simply takes too much time. The poor are not passive recipients of our help. They make their own decisions. They want sweets and not a spinach-based diet, and they make as many mistakes as we do in their dietary decisions. Except that they pay for their mistakes throughout their lives…and that of their children. The good news is that a few small incentives can make a big difference. For example, rewarding parents with 1 kg of dried beans, worth less than two dollars, increased vaccination rates from 10% to 40% in rural towns where this practice was introduced.
Regarding food, the problem is not so much the quantity as the quality of the food they consume, and especially the shortage of micronutrients. According to Duflo, the priority should be good nutrition during early childhood, since adults who have been well nourished as children are, on average, taller and smarter. And the fact that they are smarter is what makes them earn more. This suggests that governments' food development policy is wrong. The solution is not to provide more cereals, but to provide foods enriched with iodine and iron to pregnant women and parents of young children, to give antiparasitic treatments to children in schools, or to encourage parents to consume nutritional supplements. The solution is to incorporate additional nutrients into the foods people like. In several countries, the consumption of a new type of salt, enriched with both iodine and iron, has been successfully tested, but the emphasis continues on a food policy focused on cheap cereals for the poor. And providing food aid on a large scale is a logistical nightmare. More than half of the wheat and more than two-thirds of the rice is “lost” along the way, including a good portion eaten by rats. In short, a prize for those who try to improve things a lot with small improvements.



