Agriculture, development option?

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in El Día on 05/17/15.

The social demand to promote agricultural development as an example of diversification of the economy is recurrent. It is usually dotted with nostalgic references to the environmental benefits it would generate and the agricultural power we were, with ships full of fruits, flowers and vegetables that supplied the peninsular and British markets. In fact, when Canarians are asked the main economic area to develop as an alternative to tourism, 57% mention agriculture as a development alternative. This state of opinion is part of a broader current of rejection of the occupation of the territory by houses and roads and the preservation of landscapes and the rural lifestyle. This is not an isolated phenomenon in the Canary Islands, but can be extended to North America and Western Europe, where it has even given rise since the 1960s to neoruralism, a voluntary migratory movement back to the countryside, although of a much smaller amount than the forced migration for economic reasons that occurred from the countryside to the city in the preceding centuries.

But... Is agriculture really a development option for the Canary Islands? To answer this question, it is necessary to describe its evolution and current situation, as well as the competitive position of Canarian agriculture within the market, that is, its advantages and disadvantages when competing with agricultural products generated elsewhere.

In the Canary Islands, the characteristics of the territory – insularity, orography and water scarcity – have resulted in the proliferation of smallholdings. This smallholder structure, accompanied by the lack of qualified labor and the distance from the main markets, has resulted in very low comparative profitability rates. Currently, two models of agricultural exploitation coexist in the archipelago: 

• The first, based on the cultivation of mediocrities, is traditional, poorly capitalized and intended for the local market or self-consumption. It is a subsistence agriculture with low yields per unit area, characterized by the absence of modern management techniques and by the fragmentation and dispersion of property. 

• The second model, more capitalized, orients its production predominantly towards exports. These types of farms, characterized by the incorporation of technologically advanced systems such as localized irrigation, fertilizer, windbreaks or reservoirs, have become the preeminent contribution of the primary sector to the wealth of the islands. 

The Canarian primary sector has been losing relative weight within the Canarian economic structure. At the beginning of the 20th century it accounted for 65% of the GDP and in the 1950s it exceeded 30% of the GDP. Starting in the 1970s, with the growing importance of tourism, it lost weight even more rapidly and went from contributing 11% of the regional GDP in the early 1970s to 1.5% at the end of 2014. In fact, its value in current terms, without eliminating the influence of prices, has remained stable between 1995 and 2014, while the GDP of the Canary Islands economy has multiplied by 2.4 in that same period. Regarding employment, at the beginning of the 20th century the primary sector accounted for more than 80% of employment, in the 1950s 59%, 8% in 1995, and in 2010 only 2.9%. 

When talking about this return to agriculture, what is not mentioned is that agriculture was the main economic activity in the Canary Islands until the 1960s, and that during that stage it was incapable of supporting the population without having to take advantage of the escape valve of emigration. Suffice it to remember that in the 1950s, when 59% of employment was generated by agriculture, around 10% of the population (about 90,000 people) was forced to emigrate to Venezuela. And a good part of the Canarians who remained on the islands at that time survived at levels close to subsistence. Agriculture has not historically provided well-being and development to the Canary Islands. Just mere subsistence. It is the generalization of air navigation by means of jets in the years 1960 and 1975 that brought the Canary Islands closer to developed Europe and allowed a tourist “invasion” that generated in the islands the most transcendental socioeconomic change of the 20th century, creating wealth and development. 

In the world, the only two successful agricultural models are based either on large, highly technical and capital-intensive agricultural farms (case of the United States); or in an abundant and cheap labor force with salaries of 100/150 dollars per month (countries in the Caribbean, Africa, Asia and South America). Price competition is the fundamental characteristic of this sector, and the truth is that a substantial reduction in the cost structure in the Canary Islands does not seem possible, both in terms of labor and inputs (water). And extensive growth is not feasible either given the logical limitations of an island region, so the possibilities for development of the sector seem really slim.

Agricultural production in the Canary Islands is and will continue to be expensive and dependent on subsidies for its own products, and on import tariffs on competing products. And both subsidies and tariffs will end up disappearing in the long term. It is not possible to convert agriculture into a sector capable of replacing tourism as an engine of economic development. However, that doesn't mean it has nothing to offer. The excellent weather conditions of the archipelago allow it to offer high quality products, and the existence of agricultural varieties eradicated in other places gives it a differential value for a consumer with medium-high and high purchasing power, who is willing to pay more for a higher quality product, characteristic flavor, and scarce and environmentally friendly production. But that is not returning to agriculture, but rather rationalizing it.

social network

More news

INFOREM COYUNTURA TURÍSTICA DE CANARIAS Y PERPECTIVAS 3T2026

Canary Islands Tourism Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.