Article published by José Alberto León in the November 2018 issue of La Gaveta Económica.
What can be done to reduce the growing inequality in income distribution? As a long-term measure, the economic literature is conclusive: there is no investment with a greater impact to improve equality of opportunity and reduce inequality than early childhood education (from 0 to 3 years) for children from families with reduced income. Because? First, it improves the education of children from disadvantaged families, something that results in future access to better jobs with higher incomes. Second, it facilitates the reconciliation of family and work life by allowing parents (especially women) not to be forced to choose between their professional career or caring for their children, lacking sufficient funds to pay for private daycare. And third, it encourages an increase in the birth rate, which in the long term will contribute to paying pensions. Low-income citizens need public daycare centers to continue working once they have a child and not personal income tax deductions that are of no use.
The European Commission concluded in a Communication that early childhood education is what produces the greatest performance in terms of children's social adaptation. Member States should invest more in early childhood education as an effective means of laying the foundations for later learning, preventing school dropouts and increasing equality in outcomes and overall levels of competence. It is both more effective and more equitable to invest in education in early stages: correcting failures later is not only inequitable, but comparatively much less effective. This idea is not new: children from low-income families, from ethnic minorities, from immigrant or single-parent families perform worse in school and, as a consequence, there is a risk that their chances of success in their future professional lives will decrease.
The ILO report, “A Good Start: Early Childhood Education and Educators,” examines evidence that early childhood education is a cost-effective strategy for preventing or correcting delays in learning ability and disadvantages resulting from poverty and unfavorable socioeconomic conditions. In particular, the report maintains that investment in early childhood education should be considered a public good with higher rates of return than interventions aimed at older children. Likewise, research carried out in 16 Latin American countries shows that the period of life between conception and six years of age, especially between 0 and 3 years, is the most critical in the process of intergenerational transmission of poverty. During these years the vulnerability to the harmful effects of poverty is greater. On the other hand, the impact of interventions to break the reproductive cycle is, in this phase, more effective than in other stages of life. Investment in social policies for children at this stage seems to have high profitability, not only in terms of reducing future social expenses such as school repetition, school dropouts, health, social protection network, public security, attention to offenders within the penal system, but in terms of the wealth that an individual with the opportunity to develop physically, intellectually, socially, emotionally and ethically can produce in the future. These benefits are even projected into subsequent educational performance, as derived from the results of the PISA tests, which show that early schooling has a positive impact on performance in educational competencies, and record this impact by social class to which the student belongs. The educational system does not guarantee the educational rights of the youngest children nor does it promote equal opportunities, since the population from the most humble social background and with greater socioeconomic difficulties, the one who could benefit the most from early education, has the least chance of access, since they cannot pay for schooling in the first instance.
In Spain, early childhood education constitutes the first level of the educational system and is configured as an educational stage with its own identity that serves children from birth to 6 years of age. Despite being a non-compulsory stage, it has an educational nature with its own structural and curricular development. It is organized in two cycles of three school years each: the first up to 3 years of age, and the second from 3 to 6 years of age. The second cycle is free, both in public centers and in subsidized centers, while educational administrations promote the progressive increase in the supply of public places in the first cycle, which is not free. Only 35% of Spanish children in the first cycle of childhood (less than three years old) are enrolled in school. This percentage drops in the Canary Islands to 14%, and then we are surprised by our high rate of school failure and the poor results in PISA. Public early childhood education is planned through regional and local governments, and there is a huge gap between the supply of public and private places in early childhood education centers and the actual and potential volume of users.
As a measure to combat social inequality, the right to schooling before the age of three should be gradually established in Spain, so that parents could exercise it at will. In order for the exercise of this right to be financially acceptable, it could be established in phases. Following the Swedish model, the right to early school education would exist from the time the child turned one year of age, although it would still not be mandatory. In a first phase, free admission would be reserved for those families at risk of exclusion (around 30%) and the rest would assume the cost of their place, while in a second phase free admission would be extended to the entire population. The best implementation formula would be agreements with pre-existing schools, both public and private, using part of the educational infrastructure that is beginning to be underused as a result of the decline in the birth rate. The annual cost of this first phase throughout Spain would amount to about 750 million euros, and in the Canary Islands to just 40 million euros, more or less what regional television costs us. But it is clear that the priorities are different.



