Article published by José Alberto León in El Día on 05/31/15.
In the book “Why Countries Fail” by Acemoglu and Robinson, the authors conclude that countries grow economically if they are able to create “robust and well-designed inclusive institutions that, politically, guarantee participation and pluralism.” Otherwise they end up stagnating, hence the economic importance of the analysis of institutions. An example of a poorly designed institution is the election system of our regional Parliament, which is criticized, on the one hand, for the over-representation of the smaller islands over the larger ones, which leads, for example, to the vote of one person from El Hierro being “worth” as much as that of almost seventeen Tenerife residents; and, on the other hand, that a political party can obtain the same or greater number of regional deputies than another with a smaller number of votes.
These facts question the representativeness of the Autonomous Chamber and affect the allocation of economic resources. If the smaller islands are overrepresented, it will be electorally more profitable to make more investments and public spending in them than would be efficient, in order to gain the sympathies of the voters of those islands and obtain a good result in the elections. In fact, studies carried out in the United States, Brazil, Russia, Argentina, Japan and Mexico show that the disproportion between the percentage of voters and the percentage of seats has a significant impact on laws and investments by territory.
In the Canary Islands elections last week, the paradoxes have been very provocative. The most striking is that one party (ASG) won three seats with just 5,089 votes (0.6% of the total), while another (Ciudadanos) did not obtain any seats with ten times as many votes (53,981 votes, 5.93% of the total). In fact, there were six parties that obtained more votes than ASG without achieving any parliamentary representation. Likewise, the three parties with the most votes obtain disparate seats with very similar percentages of votes. And finally, no less than 173,000 votes (almost 20% of the total) go directly to the “trash” by not obtaining parliamentary representation.
Criticism of the electoral system has intensified for these reasons, and not without reason, arguing that it is not a “fair” system. However, Nobel Laureate in Economics Kenneth Arrow mathematically demonstrated what has since become known as Arrow's Paradox, which is that (expressed in non-mathematical language), \"no totally fair voting system exists nor can exist\", since some criteria for it contradict others. While this is true, it is also true that some electoral systems are fairer than others, since some meet four of the five criteria established by Arrow, while the canary barely meets one. The truth is that if we calculate the “electoral disproportion index” for the Canary Islands, the poor proportionality amounts to 33%, that is, no less than 33% of the seats in the Canary Islands are assigned to electoral constituencies that would not receive them if there were not an inadequate disproportion. This index was created by Snyder and Samuels in their work “The Value of a Vote: Malapportionment in Comparative Perspective”, and used to compare the electoral systems of the 78 democratic countries of the world in 2001. And the Canarian electoral system turns out to be the most disproportionate in the world, surpassing the worst (Tanzania, with a 26% disproportion), when the average disproportion is 7% and that of Spain is 9.6%, above the average but less than a third of that of the Canary Islands.
The defenders of the current system argue that "triple parity" (that is, that the sum of the seats in the smaller islands is the same as that of the largest, that the seats in the two provinces are the same, and that the capital islands have the same number of deputies) is untouchable for reasons of territorial balance and they are only willing to reduce the insular (30% of the votes) and regional (6% of the votes) minimum to access Parliament. The reduction of the regional minimum of 6% would have allowed, for example, the entry of Ciudadanos into Parliament, but it would maintain imbalances and inconsistencies such as more deputies being elected in La Palma (7) than in Fuerteventura (6), when the population of the latter is 28% higher than that of the beautiful island; or that the vote of one person from El Hierro “is worth” as much as that of seventeen people from Tenerife. The reality is that from the point of view of democratic theory, the disproportion between the percentage of voters and seats violates the democratic principle of “one person, one vote.”
If island constituencies are maintained, the simplest thing would be to allocate seats per island based on population, with a minimum of one seat per island. That way, El Hierro would have a seat; La Gomera, 2; La Palma, 3; Fuerteventura, 4; Lanzarote, 5; Gran Canaria, 22; and Tenerife, 23. The Canarian electoral disproportion index would be reduced to 7.7%, on average for democratic countries and below the national level.
If a territorial counterweight was established to avoid an unlikely government “of the larger islands against the smaller ones”, it would be possible to introduce a double majority system that would require that any vote require the approval of the majority of deputies and islands, counting the votes of the deputies island by island, and thus introducing a factor of territorial representation (typical of a second chamber such as the Senate) in the Parliament of the Canary Islands. It would follow the example of the double majority (more than 50% of the votes and of the states) required for constitutional changes in Australia, Canada, Switzerland and the United States; as well as in the European Council, which requires the vote of 55% of the states and 65% of the population.
What does not make sense is to maintain the current situation, which generates deep citizen unrest. If one of the complaints of 15-M, shouting “they don't represent us,” was that the national electoral system did not adequately represent citizens, what can we say about the Canary Islands, the most disproportionate in the world?



