EUROPEAN DESPOTISM

Article published by José Alberto León Alonso in Diario de Avisos on 05/25/14.

The crisis has created the conditions for citizens' disaffection with many of their institutions: political parties, unions, the Monarchy, the judiciary, the autonomous system, the euro and the European Union have been involved in controversy over their usefulness for the citizen. As always happens throughout history, in times of economic depression, solutions emerge that propose a clean slate that radically modifies the functioning of until recently generally accepted institutions. Europe has not escaped this wave of discontent and voices proposing Spain's exit from the euro and even the European Union proliferate, and the benefit obtained by our membership in the European club is discussed.

There are really few economic analyzes focused on what the behavior of the different European economies would have been if they had not joined the EU. The exception is the article "How much do countries benefit from membership in the European Union?" by Campos, Coricelli and Moretti. From their econometric analysis it is concluded that all the European countries that have joined the EU since 1981 have benefited economically except one: Greece. For Spain these benefits are permanent, that is, they occur from the first moment and never stop occurring. Thus, the Spanish GDP per capita has grown since 1986, the year of accession, almost 1 p.p. annual growth above the estimated growth without integration into Europe from the moment of enlargement to the present day, the fall in GDP would have been greater outside Europe than within it. As a result, the per capita income of Spaniards today would be almost 25% lower if integration with Europe had not occurred. As I mentioned, the only exception is Greece, whose GDP per capita would be 12% higher if it had not joined the EU in 1981. period 1981-1995, which seems to indicate that the adjustment periods agreed for its integration were unduly rapid and its economy was not able to adapt quickly. Thus, despite the populist message that “Europe does not serve us”, it seems that its usefulness to improve our standard of living is beyond doubt. However, now that we are called to vote for our representatives in the European Parliament, another very different issue is the usefulness of the European Parliament.

My opinion is no. The Commission, the Central Bank, the Court of Justice of the EU and especially the European Council have more real capacity to influence European policies than the European Parliament, reduced to a mere body for ratifying what is agreed in other instances, to give it a democratic veneer. Commission? Central Bank? Court of law? European Council? What rigmarole of institutions is this?

The institutional framework of the European Union is tremendously complex. So much so that, to make it understandable to the European citizen, the EU has prepared and disseminated a “Citizen's Guide to the EU Institutions”, which occupies no less than 44 pages, when the functioning of the institutions of any country is explained in two or three pages. There are a dozen European institutions and a multitude of agencies, but if we focus on how laws are made, it can be summarized as follows: the Council defines the general political direction and priorities of the EU and instructs the European Commission to prepare the corresponding legislation, the Commission proposes the new legislation and it is the European Parliament and again the Council who adopt them. In this institutional architecture, it is the Council that leads the EU and the Commission that executes the tasks. The Council brings together the Heads of State and Government and meets at least four times a year. Decisions are made by qualified majority, but in practice Germany sets the pace, as the most populated and economically powerful country. The Commission is the European executive body and is responsible for initiating the legislative procedure and enforcing EU law. The Council proposes a new President of the Commission every five years, who must be ratified by the European Parliament. The Commission answers to Parliament, which can present a motion of censure against it, although this has never happened (nor will it happen).

Thus, the European Parliament has shared powers with the Council for the approval of laws, although it lacks the initiative to propose them. Can you at least veto them? In theory yes, but it lacks the will to do so, since the major parties in the European Parliament support in their countries the Presidents who have reached an agreement in the Council, so they cannot be expected to oppose their own Presidents. Seeing things like this, it is not surprising that the majority groups in the European Parliament vote in the same direction 70% of the time. In this way, whoever thinks that with their vote they will decide the direction of the major European policies is going to be frustrated. That is decided in the Council, that is, it is decided by Germany and the Germans.

What is the purpose of the European Parliament then? To guarantee splendid salaries and pensions to lapsed or poorly trained politicians. For little else. European parliamentarians are like our illustrious senators: golden early retirees who will strictly follow the orders of their parties and whose decisions are never final (lest they one day rebel). All this at the modest cost of 1,800 million euros per year. A trifle. It is true that it has more legislative powers than ever, but no one would identify the direction that Europe has taken with a measure of its Parliament. It is the only parliament in the world that does not represent popular sovereignty, since it continues to reside in the member states. Don't get me wrong. The EU has been and is an excellent invention, which has forever banished the possibility of armed conflict between member countries and has generated a substantial increase in the standard of living for its citizens, but it is not a democracy. It is a system in which the government of a country decides and most of us citizens (non-Germans) lack the power to democratically “punish” it if we do not like its decisions. When the European Parliament alone makes the laws and elects a European Government with executive powers, it will serve a purpose. Or failing that, when they allow all Europeans to vote in the German elections, which are the ones that really determine the course of Europe. Meanwhile, they could save all this electoral money (and the 1.8 billion annually) to simulate a democratic appearance of what is a despotic system. The despots of the 18th century already said it: “everything for the people, but without the people.”

social network

More news

INFOREM COYUNTURA TURÍSTICA DE CANARIAS Y PERPECTIVAS 3T2026

Canary Islands Tourism Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

La Palma Economic Situation Report – Third quarter of 2026

The Canary Islands closed the first quarter of 2026 with a positive evolution of the main economic indicators of the tourism sector. This is clear from the Report prepared by Corporación 5, Analysis and Strategies for EXCELCAN and the Chamber of Commerce of Gran Canaria.

Do you need a specialized vision for your organization?

Talk to our team and let's jointly analyze the needs of your project.